Identity & Morality

What Makes Us Human?

What Measure Is a Non-Human?Humanity Is InfectiousPinocchio Syndrome
Illustration of the What Makes Us Human? trope

What it is

As the line between humans and non-humans blurs — AI, clones, aliens, robots — the story forces a reckoning with what truly defines humanity: biology, consciousness, memory, emotion, or moral choice.

How to spot it

The plot contains ALL of: (1) a non-human entity that displays human-like qualities, (2) a question — explicit or implicit — about whether this entity counts as a person, (3) the story using this question to reflect on what humanity means.

  • A non-human character demonstrates more empathy, love, or morality than humans
  • Characters debate whether an artificial or alien being has rights, a soul, or feelings
  • A non-human entity makes a sacrifice that proves its humanity
  • The story blurs the boundary between programmed behavior and genuine feeling
  • Humans are shown to be less "human" than the non-human character

Classic examples

Blade Runner ("tears in rain"), Westworld, WALL-E, Her, A.I. Artificial Intelligence, Ex Machina

No movies currently in the catalog feature this trope.